I visit Central London's latest place to be seen, the unassuming Sheperd Market restaurant Kitty Fishers
Much like the 18th
century prostitute from whom they take their name, Kitty Fishers’ reputation
precedes them. Hailed by some as this season’s Chiltern Firehouse, the waiting
list is as long and distinguished as, well, Chiltern Firehouse’s. Yet, unlike
it’s contemporary, the unassuming Shepherd Market restaurant, is modest both in
size and style.
Utilising the lower and ground
floor of an old town house, the restaurant takes up little more space than a
postage stamp but what it lacks in size it makes up for in character – and not
necessarily from the décor which has left co—owner Oz’s walls at home bare. It
is the sort of place that needs little more than a few dim lights and candles,
perhaps the odd seasonal flower and a randomly placed scatter cushion to make
you feel comfortable.
What first strikes you upon
entering the 40 cover eatery is the atmosphere, after hearing that our PM
Cameron has paid a few visits you might not jump to the conclusion that it
would be filled with infectious chatter and laughter but that’s exactly what it
has. With low lighting and velvet -clad bench seating it’s the sort of place
you could arrive at 7 and not leave ‘til close
- and I get the impression that this happens more often than not. I say this because I did exactly that.
In a totally unpretentious
way Kitty Fishers has a touch of the Speakeasy about it. Owner, manager and
waitresses all work alongside each other on the floor; proprietor Oz, pencil
pushed behind his ear and widely grinning takes orders and laughs with staff
and customers alike. His passion for the restaurant is almost palpable, affirming,
“owning a restaurant is brilliant, I get to eat THIS food,” and indeed THAT
food is sensational.
Guided down the steep stairs
to a cave-like room by the young personable manager – another ear to ear smile,
I am seated in the corner with a perfect view of other diners and also the
chefs. Upon the advice of the candidly engaging staff, I start with the bread
and burnt onion butter, that’s not a fault with the dish – that’s exactly what
it says on the menu. I remember as a child pawning my burnt toast off on to
other members of the family – namely my father (sorry about those carcinogens,
dad) so there was something invitingly nostalgic about it - a charming
smokiness combined with a creamy butter.
For the starter, I chose the
Cornish Crab served with barbequed cucumber – a revelation. Despite being
hailed a great place for steak, Kitty Fishers is first and foremost a wood
grill restaurant, and if you don’t believe it take a peek into the kitchen –
the doors are glass and the chefs as friendly as the waitresses. Whilst my
palate was shocked to bite into BBQ flavours, the freshness of cucumber and the
richness of crab all at once it thanked me right away. I also sampled the
tartare, which was much better than any I have had recently from some of
London’s famed beef shrines.
Those in the know, or perhaps
those with enough time on their hands to follow Nigella Lawson on Instagram, will
know of a dish that is not on the menu. It is in fact a Galician sirloin from a
10 year old dairy cow and when I say Kitty Fishers is not a steak restaurant
that is not to say that they do not cook it to perfection. Who knew old cows
tasted so good? The wood grill adds a certain ‘je ne sais quoi’ to the
proceedings and the dish comes with no frills, simply a slab of meat on a plate
with a sauce. Of course there are the standard seasonal vegetables to be
ordered separately creating a hearty dish, which further adds to the informal
atmosphere. It’s the sort of place I’d like to describe as serving ‘hearty
grub’ yet chefs Tomos Parry and Chris Leach take it the next level, nay next
stratosphere, with witty pairings and triumphant produce not to mention that
almost omnipresent wood grill.
Alongside
the hefty piece of meat, I wisely chose the duck, which came with rhubarb,
black cabbage and chervil root. The duck was faultless with the tart rhubarb
flavour setting it off to perfection. Aside from the generous portions and
exquisite flavours, it is the freshness of the ingredients that really stands out.
I didn’t
think Kitty Fishers would be the sort of place to pay much attention to puddings,
and having looked at that small section of the menu I feared I may have been
right. That was, however, until I polished off my lemon tart within a few short
minutes. Somehow subtly continuing that
smokiness that permeates each and every dish, the pudding was quite simply –
sublime.
Kitty
Fishers has an honesty to it: the food, the staff and even the décor. There are
no airs and graces and indeed the crowd is a mélange of class, character and
age - I sat beside a friendly table of northerners whilst a lady with top hat and
plummy tones quizzed the barman upstairs– I like to think I was a happy medium
within the mix. Relaxed enough for you not to worry about being underdressed
but not so much that you might feel annoyed at handing over more money than you
might expect for somewhere where jeans are acceptable.
If a down
to earth approach to fine dining is something that might appeal to you, I
suggest you book now…for next year. It’s
almost endearing that Kitty Fishers did not foresee their own huge success and
therefore they are not quite equipped to deal with the demand but if you do
manage to get your name on the sacred list you wont be disappointed – honestly.










